A very small study out of Texas, published in The Journal of Nutrition in June, found that intake of fructose can stimulate lipogenesis (fat production) more than intake of glucose. 1
Four men and two women were given a beverage containing 85g of either: 100% glucose, 50% each glucose and fructose, or 25% and 75% each glucose and fructose as a morning meal. Blood was analyzed immediately after consumption, and after a standard lunch 4 hours later.
"When fructose was consumed, absolute lipogenesis was 2-fold greater than when it was absent."That triglyceride production was enhanced both after the morning beverage was consumed and again after lunch, revealing a carry-over effect.
The 85g morning beverage contained one of the following:
- 85g glucose and 0g fructose
- 42.5g glucose and 42.5g fructose
- 21g glucose and 64g fructose
- 1 medium peach contains 3g glucose and 2g fructose
- 1/2 cup blueberries contains 4g glucose and 4g fructose
- 1 tablespoon pure corn syrup (100% glucose) contains 0g fructose
- 1 tablespoon high fructose corn syrup (45% glucose and 55% fructose) contains about 6g sugar, 2.7g glucose and 3.3g fructose
- 1 teaspoon sugar (sucrose, 50% glucose and 50% fructose) contains about 4g sugar, 2.0g glucose and 2.0g fructose 3
- 1 medium (21 ounce) cola beverage that contains about 58g of sugar, if it was sweetened with high fructose corn syrup, might contain about 26g glucose and 32g fructose.
- 1 medium (21 ounce) cola beverage that contains about 58g of sugar, if it was sweetened with sugar, might contain about 29g glucose and 29g fructose.
1 Dietary Sugars Stimulate Fatty Acid Synthesis In Adults, Journal of Nutrition, 2008
2 NutritionData.com is a great site for looking up nutrients in foods. It's the site I used for these figures.
3 The fructose bound in the disaccharide sucrose may not be as readily available for absorption as free fructose in high fructose corn syrup.
Two active discussions about this study:
Does Fructose Make You Fatter? (New York Times, Well Blog)
What's Making Us Fat? Maybe It's All That High-Fructose Corn Syrup (Los Angeles Times)